Beyond Vanity Metrics: How Creative Analytics Can Turn Customer Data Into Better Marketing Decisions

Marketing teams have dashboards everywhere. Whilst everything may look healthy in terms of impressions, likes, follows, and upward trends, the data isn’t really telling you anything about your revenue. This results in more dashboards! Vanity metrics are metrics that look appealing but don’t help make any decisions. Creative analytics is using the data you already have to ask better questions. It doesn’t require a data science department; it just means you want to make decisions based on visuals.

How to Use Creative Analytics to Improve Marketing Decisions

Applause Does Not Equal Behavior

A million impressions are a million opportunities to scroll past. Whilst views and likes may look nice, they aren’t showing you any impact, simply exposure. Exposure is the cheapest thing on the internet! What you really want to know is if people watched the video, clicked through and stayed on the page, or came back a week later without retargeting. Real consumer engagement will show you patterns of people taking action for free. This will show you how your revenue is doing. Whilst reach tells you how many people saw your brand, behavior tells you how many cared. Two campaigns could give you the exact same number of impressions, but whilst one is working behind the scenes, the other is wasting your budget. Only behavioral data will tell you the difference between the two.

Data Lies Nicely

The data you receive may look neutral, but it can mean many different things. An increase in traffic could be due to what you sent out that week, what your competitors have done, and what’s changed with the algorithm for no reason! Be sure to segment your data before making judgments. Are the new people coming to your site or returning? Are they coming from mobile or desktop? Is the traffic from a campaign or organic? Averages can be misleading, as they are usually two very different audiences. Splitting your averages will always reveal something interesting. Usually your main finding will come from a small segment performing better than expected.

Ask Small Questions

The best way to use analytics is to start with a decision that needs to be made. Should we double our video budget? Is our checkout copy holding us back? Then ask yourself what the smallest amount of data you can get to answer this question. Open-ended questions will give you noise. Asking why people are abandoning on mobile at the shipping stage will give you an answer that can be improved, often within an afternoon. Asking specific questions will also help you avoid any political issues. You’ll have a specific finding and improvement, which is difficult to argue with. Whereas asking general questions will lead everyone to assume their theory and move on.

Customers Aren’t Funnel Friendly

Customers aren’t funnel-friendly. They can circle around, get stuck on the pricing page for 2 weeks, find out about your brand through a creator, and then forget about you. If your data is siloed, you won’t see any of this. Each platform will give you a different snapshot of data that all looks good. However, if you track the real journey customers take from first touch to conversion, it completely changes the story. You’ll see exactly where people are dropping off. This is what a customer journey agency will do for you professionally. They will piece together the puzzle and improve the areas where people are leaving. Even doing a basic version internally will help you more than 10 dashboards. This data will age, so be sure to update it after major launches, as journeys will change the moment your product or market changes.

Complete the Loop

Use your findings to influence the next piece of work. If you’re seeing people drop off at 8 seconds on completion data, your hooks will change. If you’re seeing a certain tone increasing saves by doubling, this tone will no longer be an experiment and will become your standard. Data shouldn’t be used to judge your creativity but to brief it. Teams who complete this loop will start to see improvements. Testing, learning from behavior, changing, and testing again will give you a competitive edge. Just be sure to give each change enough time to give you genuine data. A week’s worth of reactions won’t give you a pattern. There won’t be one insight; it will be the loop.

End Point

Vanity metrics feel good, as they don’t require you to make any decisions. However, behavioral data makes you feel uncomfortable, as it requires decisions to be made, which is the whole point. Ask smaller questions, segment your data, track the real journey customers take, and use every finding to influence your next piece of creative. Your marketing will become more precise, just like anything else, by focusing on what people are actually doing.